Guest Reviews
Write a ReviewNorene
Chesterland, US
Reviewed: Sep 24, 2025
Property Manager
Working with Guy was extremely easy! He was always very informative and responsive. One of the best experiences we've ever had renting a vacation house! Thank you Guy!
Property
We love to fish, so fishing from the beach/dock was one of our favorite activities!
View Property: Serenity Bay
Joseph
Tequesta, US
Reviewed: Jul 20, 2025
Property Manager
Again, Guy was very helpful, something you do not get with a vrbo rental. Working directly gave us the one on one help. He was terrific.
Property
Conch custard was a nightly stop. Aquarium encounters was a nice place to see and explore. Bahia honda state park was awesome as usual. Was nice having the boat next to house and going out on the gulf, snorkeled the sombrero reef, enjoying the pool was relaxing as well.
View Property: Vacasa Por Cola Amarilla
William
Sewell, US
Reviewed: Jun 16, 2025
Property Manager
See above concerning our experience with Guy, He was wonderful!
Property
Where to start? Pool time was exquisite, we had a visit from a manatee that thrilled our grandkids, there were cutthroat ping pong tournaments waged among the offspring, our one son landed not one but two juvenile tarpon from one of your kayaks, some attempted almost life-sized chess and cornhole, and that was all on property! We also visited the Dolphin Research Center, the Aquarium and the Turtle Hospital. We had a total of three fishing charters so there was ample fish for hook and cook. A fantastic vacation!!!!
View Property: The Salty Lime Luxury Retreat
Johnny
Kingsland, US
Reviewed: Jun 12, 2025
Property Manager
Very friendly!
Property
Diving
Swimming
Fishing
Eating
View Property: Golfside Tropical Retreat
Genna
North Reading, US
Reviewed: May 3, 2025
Property Manager
Great location. Perfect for hosting extended family.
Property
Fishing, boat charter, key west, turtle hospital
View Property: The Salty Lime Luxury Retreat
Mark
Liberty TWP, US
Reviewed: Apr 22, 2025
Property Manager
Guy was fantastic. Very responsive and attentive to our needs.
View Property: Serenity Bay
Tammi
Coldwater, US
Reviewed: Apr 1, 2025
Property Manager
Your team is fantastic!
Property
We rented a boat from the marina next door for three days. While we were not able to keep the boat docked at the home, it was easy to make the short walk to access it.
View Property: Serenity Bay
Jim
Eustis, US
Reviewed: Mar 18, 2025
Property Manager
Guy Moreau was outstanding to work with. Would recommend him to anybody.
Property
Swimming in heated pool was a blessing for families coming in from wintery MN and Colorado. Paddled kayaks around the bay. Small grandchildren enjoyed the sandy area & looking at animals in water & around property (nurse sharks, horseshoe crabs, iguanas, any number of tropical birds). Toured the Crane Mansion property. Enjoyed the Island Fish Market & the Wooden Spoon. Went out on charter boat twice with Captain Jeff. Visited Key West & state parks. Adults sat outside in the evenings and played board games in the beautiful covered area. Enjoyed lots more activities, too numerous to list.
View Property: Serenity Bay
Andrea
Burtchville, US
Reviewed: Mar 11, 2025
Property Manager
Excellent! Responsive! Polite!
Property
We had several children on this vacation and they did the dolphin experience at the Dolphin Research Center and we also visited the Turtle Hospital. Both experiences were excellent! The kids were perfectly content staying at the vacation property/ the pool was very enjoyable, the kayaking was entertaining and the amount of space this property had was perfect!
View Property: The Salty Lime Luxury Retreat
Mary
Mobridge, US
Reviewed: Mar 7, 2025
Property Manager
Guy was easy to work with. Answered emails and texts promptly. Had an issue with shower handle and he came that same day and fixed.
Property
Dry Tortuguas Tour, Key West Shopping, Pigeon Key, Sombrero Beach
View Property: Vacasa Por Cola Amarilla
David
Munster, US
Reviewed: Jan 8, 2025
Property Manager
Guy was great to deal with. He promptly responded to all of our inquiries.
Property
We fished of the dock and hung out in the pool and hot tub most days. 2 of the days we drove to Key West for dinner and sightseeing.
View Property: Vacasa Por Cola Amarilla
Cheryl
Saint Augustine, US
Reviewed: Jan 7, 2025
Property Manager
Guy was quick to respond and had excellent communication skills.
Property
Snorkeling, kayaking, parasailing, jet ski rental, all within minutes of the rental.
View Property: The Salty Lime Luxury Retreat
Karen
Tell City, US
Reviewed: Jan 7, 2025
Property Manager
It was refreshing to have local support and not a remote person to call.
Property
We loved the local aquarium, watching sunset using the kayaks, day trip to Key West, visit to brewery in Islamadora, brunch at the Wooden Spoon.
View Property: Vacasa Por Cola Amarilla
Talia
Reviewed: Nov 8, 2024
Property Manager
Guy was friendly and informative.
Property
We went to The Lagoon at Grassy Key and had the best time. The kids had a blast, the staff was great and the food and drinks were awesome!
Charles
Grove City, US
Reviewed: Sep 10, 2024
Property Manager
Very polite and courteous!
Property
We had a boat delivered to the property, so we went out multiple times of the day fishing or just cruising. Several of us took a ride to Key West on Duval Street for night time fun. Kids and adults enjoyed seeing the manatees and iguanas around the dock. Big fun!
View Property: The Salty Lime Luxury Retreat
Judy A
Abbeville, US
Reviewed: Aug 14, 2024
Anne
Billerica, US
Reviewed: Jul 20, 2024
Property Manager
Guy was super responsive and helpful!
View Property: Serenity Bay
Aimie
Carriere, US
Reviewed: Jul 17, 2024
Johnny
Kingsland, US
Reviewed: Jun 17, 2024
Property Manager
Very pleasant.
Property
Fishing
Diving
Swimming in the pool.
View Property: Golfside Tropical Retreat
Lori
Jasper, US
Reviewed: May 21, 2024
Property Manager
Very responsive and helpful on any concerns or questions we had.
Property
Snorkeling with Captain Pips was our favorite activity. They were great!
View Property: Serenity Bay
Kennth
ALEDO, US
Reviewed: Apr 16, 2024
Property Manager
Great communication
View Property: Golfside Tropical Retreat
David
Raleigh, US
Reviewed: Apr 9, 2024
Property Manager
Guy was great made entering and exiting easy
Property
Take the kayaks out and fish the sallow waters
View Property: Vacasa Por Cola Amarilla
Lynn
Ely, US
Reviewed: Mar 19, 2024
Property Manager
Guy was absolutely amazing. His attention to details and quick response to questions was so great!
Property
We saw manatees from the dock. There are also large iguanas in the trees. Fun to watch and find them each day. The pool and spa were amazing. The fire pit and seating was our favorite hangout. Spent most of our time outside unless the nats got too bad. No Natz works pretty well for most.
Master bedroom was great. Nice that it was on one side away from the other bedrooms. Very comfortable bed and linens.
View Property: Vacasa Por Cola Amarilla
Kerrie
Monticello, US
Reviewed: Mar 19, 2024
Property Manager
I loved the team! It was a smoothless experience.
Property
We brought out boat so we did a lot of boating. We also went to the turtle hospital. We wanted to do dry tortugas but you must book way out in advance
View Property: Private lil Get-A-Way
Timothy
Rome, US
Reviewed: Mar 7, 2024
Property Manager
Guy is great, and provides perfect service.
Property
-Day trip to Key West is always a highlight (75 min drive). We spend the entire day there.
-Sombrero Beach is an awesome beach. Great for families.
-Favorite restaurants: Keys Fisheries, Island Fish Co., Porkys, Hogfish Bar & Grill (Stock Island), Sweet Savannahs AND Conch Custard for ice cream!
-Key Lime Pie from as many diff places as possible. Sweet Savannahs, SS Wreck, and BlueHeaven were our top 3 in the keys.
-Kids got a big kick out of the deer on Big Pine Key. They have zero fear of people and will literally walk inches past you. We ate at No Name Pub (food was just ok, but cool location and charm). There were several deer in the parking lot there.
-we attended a turtle release at Sombrero. My kids enjoyed that as well. Pay attention to Facebook for dates. Apparently it happens somewhat often.
-we spent a lot of time at home as well. The backyard is almost like a mini-resort. Much time spent swimming in the pool, kayaking in the canal, drinks by the fire at night, and just soaking up the sun!
View Property: Vacasa Por Cola Amarilla